Back to the library

Key question New

AI-processed · Author-approved

How can organizations successfully replace critical legacy IT systems when gradual rollout is impossible?

Digital Renewal Under Extreme Constraints: Insights From a Successful Implementation of an Election Management System
Jon Aaen, Ulrik Røhl, Jeppe Agger Nielsen · International Conference on Information Systems (ICIS) · 2026
Illustration for: How can organizations successfully replace critical legacy IT systems when gradual rollout is impossible?

Loads Spotify's player; Spotify may set cookies. This device remembers your choice.

Key findings

  • Identifies three core organizing principles that facilitated a successful simultaneous nationwide system transition without operational disruption.
  • Shows that conservative renewal limits change by intentionally using legacy system logic and workflows as design benchmarks to reduce operational and technical friction.
  • Demonstrates that cautious renewal promotes reliable deployment through early rehearsals, a shared acute awareness of failure consequences, and stakeholder willingness to compromise on non-critical functional desires.
  • Finds that collaborative renewal resolves centralization tensions by pairing centralized platform governance with decentralized local execution and autonomy.

What it means for you

CIO / IT Executive

Evaluate whether aligning design choices with legacy workflows is appropriate for your context when prioritizing high reliability and operational continuity.

IT Manager

Incorporate early rehearsals and failure-mode analysis into deployment planning to build shared acute awareness among stakeholders.

Business Strategist

Design governance models that balance centralized platform control with decentralized local autonomy to resolve operational tensions.

Researcher

Conduct further empirical investigations into digital renewal processes specifically within high-reliability organizational contexts.

Policymaker

Consider how strict temporal and cybersecurity constraints influence stakeholder willingness to compromise on non-critical functional requirements during major public IT transitions.

Summary

This qualitative case study examines the replacement of Denmark's nationwide election management system under severe temporal, functional, and cybersecurity constraints. Guided by High Reliability Organization theory, the researchers analyzed 24 interviews with key stakeholders, direct observations across polling stations, and project documentation.

Problem

Prevailing IT renewal frameworks assume organizations can use agile, modular, or phased rollouts to learn and correct course over time. However, transitioning mission-critical systems can be challenging due to tight deadlines, the need to maintain operational continuity, and dependencies across interconnected environments.

Transcript
Host: Welcome to A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. I'm Anna Ivy Summers.

Expert: And I'm Alex Ian Sutherland.

Host: Today, we are looking at a study titled "Digital Renewal Under Extreme Constraints: Insights From a Successful Implementation of an Election Management System." It was presented at the International Conference on Information Systems in 2026 by researchers Jon Aaen, Ulrik Røhl, and Jeppe Agger Nielsen. The study examines how Denmark replaced its nationwide election management platform under severe time, functional, and cybersecurity constraints.

Expert: Most standard IT management frameworks recommend agile, modular, or phased rollouts. The assumption is that teams can launch incrementally, learn from operational errors, and correct course over time.

Host: But that approach assumes an organization can tolerate trial and error in production. What happens when operational continuity is mandatory?

Expert: That is precisely the problem this study addresses. When replacing mission-critical core systems across interconnected organizations, a single failure can halt operations entirely. In the Danish case, ninety-eight independent municipalities had to switch simultaneously on election day. Because of strict statutory deadlines and high cybersecurity threats, a phased rollout was not an option.

Host: How did the researchers investigate this transition?

Expert: The authors conducted a qualitative case study framed by High Reliability Organization theory. They analyzed twenty-four in-depth interviews with key stakeholders across local municipalities, central agencies, and IT vendors. They also combined this with direct observations at polling stations and extensive internal project documentation.

Host: What were the core findings on how this transition was managed without operational disruption?

Expert: The study identifies three central organizing principles: conservative renewal, cautious renewal, and collaborative renewal.

Host: Let us start with conservative renewal. What does that involve?

Expert: Conservative renewal limits the scope of functional change. Rather than redesigning processes or introducing novel interfaces, the project team deliberately replicated legacy system logic and workflows as their design benchmark. This reduced operational friction and lowered the learning curve for thousands of municipal workers on election day.

Host: And what defines cautious renewal?

Expert: Cautious renewal is built on early rehearsals and an explicit awareness of failure consequences. Project leaders conducted multiple full-scale tests under simulated operational conditions. Because stakeholders across all organizations understood the public stakes of a system failure, they were willing to compromise by dropping non-essential feature requests to protect core reliability.

Host: That brings us to collaborative renewal. How did they resolve tensions between centralized control and local municipal autonomy?

Expert: Collaborative renewal paired centralized platform governance with decentralized local execution. The central project team governed the core platform, technical standards, and cybersecurity configurations. Meanwhile, local municipalities retained autonomy over their own staffing, physical polling setups, and internal training procedures.

Host: Looking at the broader picture, why does this matter for business leaders and technology executives?

Expert: It highlights that modernizing mission-critical systems does not always require radical process re-engineering. In high-reliability environments, anchoring system design to legacy operational logic can be a deliberate risk-mitigation strategy. Furthermore, when independent business units or partners must adopt a shared platform simultaneously, centralizing the technical architecture while allowing local operational autonomy reduces implementation friction.

Host: To summarize, the study demonstrates that digital renewal under severe constraints relies on scoping changes conservatively, running rigorous pre-deployment rehearsals, and balancing centralized governance with local autonomy. Alex, thank you for sharing these insights.

Expert: You are welcome, Anna.

Host: And thank you for listening to A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. Join us next time for more practical analyses of emerging technology research.
Artificial Intelligence & Automation Information Systems & Management Human-Computer Interaction Data Analytics & Big Data Digital Transformation & Strategy Cybersecurity & Privacy Cloud & Infrastructure E-Commerce & Digital Platforms Operations & Supply Chain Sustainability & Green IS

digital renewal, critical IT, High Reliability Organization, election management system, IT implementation, case study