Back to the library

Key question New

AI-processed · Author-approved

How does generative AI adoption trigger power struggles across departments, and how are these tensions resolved?

Generative AI implementation and the shift of power dynamics in established organizations
Joel Jose Rivera Jimenez, Simone Gabbriellini, Chiara Frigerio · International Conference on Information Systems (ICIS) · 2026
Illustration for: How does generative AI adoption trigger power struggles across departments, and how are these tensions resolved?

Loads Spotify's player; Spotify may set cookies. This device remembers your choice.

Key findings

  • Introducing generative AI disrupts departmental hierarchies, elevating technical units to strategic roles while prompting incumbent managers to actively contest project ownership.
  • Inter-departmental coordination triggers resistance driven by fears of workforce reductions and the loss of knowledge-gatekeeper authority.
  • Leaders deploy augmentation narratives emphasizing workforce enhancement rather than replacement to reduce resistance, even when broad corporate goals center on cost efficiency.
  • Tensions are ultimately settled through negotiated, incremental deployments that favor institutional stability and familiar vendor relationships over technically radical transformations.

What it means for you

CIO / IT Executive

Schedule a joint Monday morning sync with business unit heads to establish a co-ownership model for upcoming AI projects, directly countering fears of IT power-grabs by formally sharing project governance.

IT Manager

Draft an explicit 'augmentation-first' communication brief for your engineering team to use in all cross-departmental meetings, emphasizing that AI tools exist to enhance—not replace—incumbent staff expertise.

Business Strategist

Audit your current AI deployment roadmap and restructure the rollout into small, incremental milestones that preserve familiar departmental workflows and existing vendor partnerships to minimize political resistance.

Researcher

Design your next interview protocol to specifically investigate how middle managers use knowledge-gatekeeping tactics to contest AI-driven resource reallocation across departments.

Policymaker

Draft regulatory guidelines that require financial institutions to include cross-departmental impact assessments and worker consultation clauses before approving large-scale generative AI deployments.

Summary

This qualitative study investigates how generative AI adoption reshapes and is influenced by horizontal power dynamics between organizational departments. Using grounded theory methods, the researchers analyzed 40 semi-structured interviews with C-level executives and senior leaders across 20 Italian financial institutions. From these findings, the authors develop a three-stage process model covering organizing, coordination, and deployment.

Problem

Up to 95 percent of enterprise AI initiatives fail, yet implementation research rarely addresses horizontal power struggles between departments. Generative AI alters governance structures and resource allocation, threatening established departmental influence and creating resistance that traditional top-down frameworks fail to explain.

Transcript
Host: Welcome to A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. I'm Anna Ivy Summers.

Expert: And I'm Alex Ian Sutherland. Today, we are discussing a study titled "Generative AI Implementation and the Shift of Power Dynamics in Established Organizations," presented at the International Conference on Information Systems, 2026, by Joel Jose Rivera Jimenez, Simone Gabbriellini, and Chiara Frigerio.

Host: This study examines how the adoption of generative AI reshapes, and is reshaped by, horizontal power relationships between different organizational departments. Alex, early reports suggest that up to 95 percent of enterprise AI initiatives fail. Why is departmental power such a critical factor here?

Expert: Most implementation research looks at power vertically, between managers and their subordinates. But generative AI requires new organizational structures, dedicated competence centers, and substantial resources. When these new units emerge, they alter established boundaries. Departments that once held significant influence suddenly face changes to their budgets, responsibilities, and authority. If leadership treats AI deployment purely as a technical rollout rather than a political negotiation across departments, projects frequently stall.

Host: To examine this dynamic, what approach did the researchers take?

Expert: The authors applied grounded theory methods within the Italian financial sector, where AI adoption is accelerating rapidly. They conducted 40 semi-structured interviews with C-level executives and senior managers across 20 banks and insurance institutions. By interviewing leaders from IT, data, innovation, and core business units, they mapped how power is contested throughout the implementation lifecycle.

Host: From that data, they developed a three-stage model: organizing, coordination, and deployment. What happens in the first stage?

Expert: In the organizing stage, structural changes create an organizational power gap. Technical units such as IT, Data, and Innovation gain strategic influence rather than remaining purely supportive functions. In response, established incumbent departments contest the ownership of generative AI initiatives. They use existing corporate hierarchies to retain control over budgets and strategic direction.

Host: Once initiatives move to coordination, what tensions emerge?

Expert: Two primary forms of resistance appear. First, there is status anxiety. In many traditional institutions, managerial influence is directly tied to the headcount one oversees. If generative AI threatens to automate tasks and reduce team sizes, managers push back. Second, individual "knowledge gatekeepers"—experts whose authority relies on controlling scarce operational information—resist tools that democratize that knowledge across the firm.

Host: How do implementation leaders navigate that pushback?

Expert: They frequently deploy augmentation narratives. They frame generative AI as an assistant that frees employees from routine tasks, rather than a tool meant for replacement. Interestingly, the study points out that while implementation teams use augmentation language locally to secure buy-in, overarching corporate goals may still target long-term efficiency and workforce reductions.

Host: That brings us to the final stage, deployment. How are these tensions ultimately reconciled?

Expert: Through negotiated implementation. To prevent outright resistance, organizations tend to avoid radical operational disruption. Instead, they choose tactical, incremental rollouts. Managers often compromise on technical optimality—sometimes sticking with existing legacy vendors or smaller process tweaks—in order to preserve departmental stability and avoid alarming internal stakeholders.

Host: What are the key takeaways for business leaders planning generative AI initiatives?

Expert: First, recognize that resistance often stems from horizontal incentives, not just technical friction. If an AI tool reduces a manager's headcount or exposes proprietary expertise, that manager has a rational incentive to slow adoption. Second, leaders should evaluate the trade-offs of negotiated implementations. While incremental adoption maintains peace and preserves institutional stability, it can also lead firms to bypass higher-performing technical solutions. Managing these power balances explicitly is essential for long-term integration.

Host: In short, successfully implementing generative AI is as much about managing inter-departmental governance and authority as it is about the technology itself. Thank you for breaking down the study, Alex.

Expert: It was a pleasure, Anna.

Host: And thank you for listening to A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. Join us next time for more practical research insights.
Artificial Intelligence & Automation Information Systems & Management Human-Computer Interaction Data Analytics & Big Data Digital Transformation & Strategy Cybersecurity & Privacy Cloud & Infrastructure E-Commerce & Digital Platforms Operations & Supply Chain Sustainability & Green IS

Generative AI, Power Dynamics, Grounded Theory, Change Management, IT Implementation, Financial Institutions