Back to the library

Key question

AI-processed · Author-approved

How can organizations automatically discover practical process improvement ideas directly from their operational workflow data?

The FLAC Method: Data-Facilitated Discovery of Business Process Improvement Options
Tobias Fehrer, Laura Marcus, Maximilian Röglinger, et al. · European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS) · 2024

16 views

Illustration for: How can organizations automatically discover practical process improvement ideas directly from their operational workflow data?

Loads Spotify's player; Spotify may set cookies. This device remembers your choice.

Key findings

  • Establishes the FLAC framework to systematically convert abstract improvement patterns into four rule types: Fitness, Location, Attribute, and Constraint.
  • Separates the one-time, expert-heavy task of formulating rules from the repeatable, automated application of those rules across multiple processes.
  • Successfully demonstrates the automatic generation and ranking of improvement options across four redesign patterns in a purchase-to-pay process.
  • BPM experts confirmed that the automated prototype delivered high-quality recommendations while significantly cutting the manual effort and time-to-insight.

What it means for you

CIO / IT Executive

Allocate budget to integrate the FLAC method software prototype into your organization's existing process mining platform to automate the generation of redesign recommendations.

IT Manager

Pull the event logs for your highest-volume operational process and task an analyst with translating one abstract improvement heuristic into a programmable rule using FLAC criteria.

Business Strategist

Review the automatically generated and ranked improvement options from your process mining platform to identify top-performing redesign patterns for the purchase-to-pay workflow.

Researcher

Investigate how to expand the FLAC method's current set of four redesign patterns (Fitness, Location, Attribute, Constraint) to handle more complex, multi-system enterprise event logs.

Policymaker

Draft guidelines encouraging government or heavily regulated agencies to adopt automated, data-driven process mining methods like FLAC to audit public service workflows objectively and transparently.

Summary

This study introduces the FLAC method, a structured approach that translates conceptual process improvement best practices into automated, programmable rulesets. Developed using design science research and situational method engineering, the method assesses process fitness, location, attributes, and constraints using event log data. The authors validated the method by implementing a software prototype in a process mining platform and evaluating it with domain experts.

Problem

Traditional business process improvement relies heavily on scarce, expensive experts and static process models that quickly become outdated. Although process mining captures rich execution data, organizations lack systematic, scalable methods to automatically turn abstract improvement heuristics into concrete, data-driven redesign recommendations.

Transcript
Host: Welcome to A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. I am Anna Ivy Summers, and today we are looking into a groundbreaking study titled "The FLAC Method: Data-Facilitated Discovery of Business Process Improvement Options." In a nutshell, this study introduces a structured method to translate high-level business process improvement best practices into automated, programmable rulesets. Joining me to break it down is our analyst, Alex Ian Sutherland. Welcome, Alex.

Expert: Thanks, Anna. It is great to be here. This study tackles a challenge that almost every modern enterprise grapples with: how to systematically fix inefficiencies in their day-to-day operations without constantly relying on expensive external consultants.

Host: Let us start with that big problem. Organizations spend millions trying to optimize their workflows, yet many initiatives stall or fail. What is going wrong with traditional business process improvement?

Expert: Traditionally, business process improvement, or BPI, relies heavily on static process models—think flowcharts and documentation created in workshops. These models are often outdated before the ink even dries, and they completely miss the messy reality of actual execution. On top of that, you need a rare mix of deep BPM methodology experts and on-the-ground business specialists to figure out what to change. Because both types of talent are scarce, process improvement ends up being slow, manual, and nearly impossible to scale across an entire enterprise.

Host: But many companies are investing in process mining now, which looks at actual event logs and system data. Has that not solved the issue?

Expert: Process mining gives you incredible visibility into what is happening, but it usually stops at diagnosis and compliance checking. It tells you where the bottlenecks are, but it does not tell you how to redesign the process to fix them. There has been a major gap between gaining data insights and taking concrete improvement actions. Process experts have abstract heuristics—like "parallelize independent tasks" or "empower frontline workers"—but translating those conceptual ideas into actionable, data-backed steps has remained a purely manual exercise.

Host: That brings us straight to the solution proposed in the study: the FLAC method. Alex, can you explain how this framework works in plain terms?

Expert: Absolutely. FLAC is an acronym that stands for Fitness, Location, Attribute, and Constraint. It is a systematic way to take any abstract improvement pattern and convert it into code that can automatically evaluate an event log. First, Fitness asks: does this pattern even make sense for our process right now? If a process is already highly parallelized, you stop there and save computing power. Second, Location searches the data to find where the pattern could apply—for instance, which specific sequence of activities might be run in parallel. Third, Attribute scores and ranks those locations based on measurable parameters, like task duration or handover frequencies, so managers see the most impactful options first. Finally, Constraint checks whether current organizational boundaries, like data dependencies or resource availability, would be violated.

Host: What strikes me as brilliant here is how it divides the labor. It separates the heavy lifting into two distinct phases.

Expert: Exactly. You only need senior process experts once: to define and program the FLAC rules for an improvement pattern. After that programmable ruleset is created and stored in a library, anyone—even junior analysts or process owners without redesign expertise—can run it against different event logs again and again. That fundamentally democratizes process improvement.

Host: The researchers did not just design the theory; they built a working prototype and tested it on real-world data. What did their demonstration look like?

Expert: They implemented the rulesets in a leading process mining platform, Celonis EMS, using four classic redesign patterns: parallelism, case assignment, resource empowerment, and activity automation. They ran these rules against an actual purchase-to-pay process log. In the parallelism test, the algorithm instantly analyzed the sequence of procurement steps, verified that the process had room for improvement, and generated four concrete, ranked redesign options complete with estimated time savings and constraint checks.

Host: And then they had domain experts evaluate the output. What were the key findings from those evaluations?

Expert: They brought in seven seasoned process management experts from both academia and industry. The experts rated the quality of the automated recommendations an impressive eight out of ten. Crucially, when comparing the prototype against manual improvement brainstorming, every single expert stated that the effort required was either "lower" or "significantly lower." The overall perceived usefulness scored over eight out of ten. The experts noted that it dramatically cuts down complexity by filtering out irrelevant noise and instantly highlighting viable candidates for redesign.

Host: That brings us to why this matters so much for business leaders and operational teams. What are the key takeaways for organizations trying to stay competitive?

Expert: The primary takeaway is a drastic reduction in time-to-insight. Instead of spending months interviewing staff to map out potential improvements, automated rulesets can scan enterprise event logs and surface ranked, data-backed recommendations in minutes. Second, it allows continuous, scalable process improvement. As market conditions shift or systems update, you can re-run these rules to spot new optimization opportunities automatically. Third, it changes the role of human managers from manual detectives to strategic decision-makers who evaluate clear, evidence-based options.

Host: It essentially turns process optimization from an occasional, high-friction project into an always-on, data-driven capability.

Expert: Precisely. It allows organizations to scale best practices across thousands of processes without multiplying headcount.

Host: To summarize: this study provides a clear, practical bridge between process mining data and real-world redesign. By transforming abstract best practices into four measurable dimensions—Fitness, Location, Attribute, and Constraint—the FLAC method paves the way for automated, scalable business process improvement. Alex, thank you so much for sharing these valuable insights with us today.

Expert: It was my pleasure, Anna.

Host: And thank you to our listeners for tuning in to A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. Be sure to subscribe, and join us next time as we unpack more cutting-edge research shaping the future of business and technology.
Artificial Intelligence & Automation Information Systems & Management Human-Computer Interaction Data Analytics & Big Data Digital Transformation & Strategy Cybersecurity & Privacy Cloud & Infrastructure E-Commerce & Digital Platforms Operations & Supply Chain Sustainability & Green IS

business process improvement, process mining, business process redesign, redesign patterns, situational method engineering, process automation