Key question New
AI-processed · Author-approved
How do different national regulations and industry strategies shape how financial data is shared across institutions?
Loads Spotify's player; Spotify may set cookies. This device remembers your choice.
Key findings
- Identifies three primary governance tensions across jurisdictions: mandatory versus voluntary participation, liability and data protection allocation, and standards governance.
- Compares three distinct governance approaches: the UK's regulator-led sandbox experimentation model, the EU's legislative statutory-rights framework, and the US's industry-led voluntary standard-setting regime.
- Demonstrates that technical standards are contested strategic assets that distribute ecosystem power and control rather than neutral technical tools.
- Finds that coercive regulatory pressures are perceived asymmetrically, with fintechs and regulators viewing mandates as leveling mechanisms, while incumbent institutions view them as costly compliance burdens.
What it means for you
CIO / IT Executive
Audit your API infrastructure to separate baseline security protocols from proprietary data formats, ensuring your team controls the integration layers before industry standards shift.
IT Manager
Inventory all third-party screen-scraping and data-sharing integrations currently in use, and map out the exact data fields exposed to determine your current liability exposure.
Business Strategist
Draft a positioning memo assessing whether your firm's open finance roadmap relies on a US-style voluntary model or an EU-style statutory framework, and calculate the cost impact if mandates arrive.
Researcher
Select two distinct open finance jurisdictions (e.g., the UK and the US) to analyze how differing technical standards actively distribute market power between incumbents and fintechs.
Policymaker
Draft a stakeholder consultation paper focusing specifically on liability allocation for data misuse in open finance to bridge the gap between mandatory compliance and market-led innovation.
Summary
This study examines how shared digital infrastructure in open finance is governed across different regulatory environments. Using an interpretive comparative case design combining institutional and stakeholder theories, the authors analyze policy documents and exploratory stakeholder interviews from the UK, the European Union, and the United States.
Problem
Expanding open banking into full open finance across investments, pensions, and insurance creates complex challenges regarding shared digital infrastructure, data security, and accountability. Financial institutions, regulators, and fintech firms disagree sharply on whether participation should be mandatory or market-led, who should bear liability for data misuse, and who controls the underlying technical standards.
Transcript
Expert: And I'm Alex Ian Sutherland.
Host: Today, we are discussing a study titled "Governing Open Finance: A Comparative Analysis of Regulation, Standards, and Stakeholder Strategy" by Sarah Zhang and Wendy Currie, presented at the International Conference on Information Systems in 2026. Alex, could you start by explaining what Open Finance involves and why its governance is so challenging?
Expert: Open Banking allowed consumers to share payment and current account data with third parties through secure application programming interfaces, or APIs. Open Finance extends that concept across the entire financial spectrum, including pensions, mortgages, investments, and insurance. The challenge is that creating this shared digital infrastructure requires agreement on how it should be governed. Regulators, incumbent institutions, and fintechs often disagree on whether participation should be legally mandated or voluntary, who carries liability for data misuse, and who controls the underlying technical standards.
Host: How did the authors examine these governance dynamics across different regions?
Expert: The study adopted an interpretive comparative case approach, examining the United Kingdom, the European Union, and the United States. The authors combined institutional theory, which looks at coercive, mimetic, and normative pressures, with stakeholder theory to evaluate how different organizations respond to those pressures. Their empirical basis includes six primary policy and regulatory documents from bodies like the Financial Conduct Authority, the European Commission, and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, supplemented by exploratory interviews with a UK regulator and a US standard-setting organization.
Host: What were the primary findings regarding the governance tensions across these jurisdictions?
Expert: The study identified three major tensions: mandatory versus voluntary participation, liability and data protection, and standards governance. It also outlined three distinct jurisdictional models. The UK follows a regulator-led approach, using mechanisms like regulatory sandboxes and TechSprints to test use cases iteratively before introducing legislation. The EU relies on a legislative model, establishing statutory data access rights through frameworks like the Financial Data Access proposal, while providing less direct leadership on technical infrastructure. The US presents a market-led model, relying primarily on voluntary industry bodies like the Financial Data Exchange, particularly as federal rulemaking has faced rollbacks.
Host: Did the study note differences in how stakeholders view regulatory interventions?
Expert: Yes. The study found that coercive regulatory pressures are perceived asymmetrically. Regulators and fintech firms generally view statutory mandates as a necessary mechanism to ensure fair competition and consumer access. Conversely, incumbent institutions, such as established banks, frequently view mandates as costly compliance burdens that may benefit less-regulated third parties, and they tend to advocate for voluntary, market-driven adoption.
Host: What did the study find regarding the role of technical standards?
Expert: The authors observed that technical standards are not merely neutral specifications. Instead, they operate as strategic assets that distribute control, power, and resources within the ecosystem. Deciding who leads standard setting determines who bears implementation costs and who influences system architecture.
Host: For business leaders and IT practitioners, what are the practical takeaways from this study?
Expert: First, organizations operating internationally cannot rely on a single governance or compliance strategy. In the UK, firms should actively participate in sandboxes and regulatory sprints to help shape emerging frameworks. In the EU, compliance teams must prepare for statutory access mandates while navigating operational tensions between financial regulations and GDPR consent requirements. In the US, firms should focus their resources on participating in voluntary standard-setting bodies like the Financial Data Exchange to help establish interoperable protocols. Second, technical leaders must align their API design, data schemas, and consent architectures directly with the specific regulatory and liability frameworks of each jurisdiction in which they operate.
Host: In summary, governing Open Finance requires navigating distinct regional balances between legal mandates and industry-led standards. Thank you, Alex, for sharing these insights.
Expert: You're welcome, Anna.
Host: And thank you to our listeners for joining us on A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. Until next time.
Open Finance, Open Banking, Regulatory Governance, Technical Standards, API, Digital Infrastructure