Back to the library

Key question New

AI-processed · Author-approved

Why are push notifications often more effective than search-based mobile ads, and where does that advantage matter most?

Push vs. Pull in Mobile Advertising: The Role of Cognitive Load in Consumer Response
Dominik Molitor, Martin Spann, Anindya Ghose · International Conference on Information Systems (ICIS) · 2026
Illustration for: Why are push notifications often more effective than search-based mobile ads, and where does that advantage matter most?

Loads Spotify's player; Spotify may set cookies. This device remembers your choice.

Key findings

  • Push notifications significantly increased coupon response rates compared to pull browsing (44.7% vs. 14.3%).
  • Mobile push delivery significantly lowered perceived cognitive load, which partially mediated the positive impact on response rates.
  • Higher local store density increased perceived cognitive load, and push delivery provided significantly greater cognitive-load reduction in high-density environments.
  • Prior app usage experience significantly reduced overall cognitive load, but did not significantly moderate the effectiveness of push notifications.
  • Cognitive load only partially mediated response behavior, leaving a large direct effect that indicates additional behavioral factors contribute to the advantage of push delivery.

What it means for you

CIO / IT Executive

Allocate development resources to build out proactive push notification infrastructure over user-initiated pull search features.

IT Manager

Configure the mobile app's push notification service to dynamically trigger location-based offers when users enter high-density retail zones.

Business Strategist

Shift mobile advertising budgets away from reactive search discovery and prioritize direct push campaigns to leverage their higher conversion rates.

Researcher

Design a follow-up experimental study to isolate the remaining direct behavioral factors driving the push-versus-pull conversion gap beyond cognitive load.

Policymaker

Draft regulatory frameworks that require explicit, granular user consent mechanisms specifically for location-triggered mobile push marketing.

Summary

This study examines whether cognitive load explains why mobile push notifications typically outperform pull-based search ads in driving consumer action. The authors conducted a 2×2×2 between-subjects online mobile experiment with 1,600 participants in the United States, manipulating ad delivery mode, prior app usage experience, and local store density. They analyzed the direct and indirect effects of these factors on perceived choice difficulty and coupon response decisions.

Problem

Firms investing in mobile marketing face a strategic trade-off between interrupting users with proactive push notifications and relying on user-initiated pull discovery. While field evidence shows push campaigns often outperform pull targeting, the underlying behavioral and decision-making mechanisms driving this gap remain unclear. Understanding these cognitive processes is essential for designing effective interfaces and targeting strategies across different competitive environments.

Transcript
Host: Welcome to A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. I'm Anna Ivy Summers, and today we are discussing a study titled "Push vs. Pull in Mobile Advertising: The Role of Cognitive Load in Consumer Response" by Dominik Molitor, Martin Spann, and Anindya Ghose, presented at the International Conference on Information Systems. Alex, welcome.
Expert: Thank you, Anna. This study evaluates why proactive mobile push notifications frequently lead to higher consumer conversion than pull-based discovery, focusing specifically on the cognitive load, or mental effort, consumers experience during decision-making.
Host: Mobile marketers often debate whether to proactively alert users via push notifications or rely on pull browsing where users search on their own. What core problem does this study address?
Expert: While empirical data shows that push campaigns regularly achieve higher response rates than pull discovery, the behavioral mechanism driving that performance gap has not been well understood. Marketers need to understand whether this gap stems from reduced mental effort, and how factors like competitor density influence that relationship.
Host: How did the researchers examine this mechanism?
Expert: They conducted a randomized online mobile experiment with 1,600 participants in the United States using a two-by-two-by-two between-subjects design. They manipulated three factors: the ad delivery mode, which was push versus pull; prior app usage experience; and local store density, representing the number of competing stores nearby. They then recorded perceived choice difficulty and coupon redemption decisions.
Host: Let us look at the findings. What did the data reveal about response rates?
Expert: Push notifications resulted in a 44.7 percent coupon response rate, compared to 14.3 percent for pull browsing.
Host: That is a measurable difference. How did cognitive load account for it?
Expert: The analysis showed that push delivery significantly reduced perceived cognitive load, which partially mediated the positive effect on response rates. However, because it was only partial mediation, a substantial direct effect remained. This indicates that lower mental effort explains a portion of the push advantage, but other behavioral factors also contribute.
Host: How did the physical shopping environment affect these dynamics?
Expert: Higher local store density increased perceived cognitive load across the board. When consumers faced more local retail options, choice difficulty rose. However, push notifications provided a significantly larger reduction in cognitive load in high-density environments compared to low-density ones.
Host: Did prior experience with the mobile app change these outcomes?
Expert: Prior app experience did reduce overall cognitive load for users, but it did not significantly moderate the effectiveness of push notifications. Push delivery maintained its relative advantage regardless of whether a user was familiar with the application.
Host: Moving to practical applications, what does this mean for marketing practitioners?
Expert: First, push messaging is particularly effective in high-density commercial areas, such as shopping malls or urban retail districts. In those locations, consumers face higher choice complexity, and push messages offer a direct way to reduce that processing burden.
Host: Does this also inform how companies should design their mobile interfaces?
Expert: Yes. Because lowering cognitive load directly supports response rates, brands should streamline promotional interfaces to minimize decision steps. However, since cognitive load only partially explains the outcome, marketers should recognize that factors like immediate delivery and salience also play roles, which must be balanced against consumer preferences to avoid message fatigue.
Host: To summarize, push notifications improve response rates in part by reducing the mental effort required to evaluate choices, an effect that is especially pronounced in crowded retail environments. Thank you, Alex, for sharing these insights.
Expert: You are welcome, Anna.
Host: And thank you for listening to A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. Join us again next time.
Artificial Intelligence & Automation Information Systems & Management Human-Computer Interaction Data Analytics & Big Data Digital Transformation & Strategy Cybersecurity & Privacy Cloud & Infrastructure E-Commerce & Digital Platforms Operations & Supply Chain Sustainability & Green IS

Mobile Advertising, Cognitive Load, Push Notifications, Pull Advertising, Store Density, Consumer Decision Making