Back to the library

Key question New

AI-processed · Author-approved

How do custom software and business domain knowledge differently affect vendor opportunism and coordination in IT outsourcing?

Domain or Software? Unpacking Knowledge Specificity and its Relational Consequences in IT Outsourcing
Oliver Krancher · International Conference on Information Systems (ICIS) · 2026
Illustration for: How do custom software and business domain knowledge differently affect vendor opportunism and coordination in IT outsourcing?

Loads Spotify's player; Spotify may set cookies. This device remembers your choice.

Key findings

  • Software knowledge specificity is positively and significantly associated with greater knowledge transfer to the vendor and increased opportunistic behavior.
  • Software knowledge specificity is not significantly associated with project coordination problems.
  • Domain knowledge specificity is positively and significantly associated with increased coordination problems between client and vendor teams.
  • Domain knowledge specificity shows no significant association with vendor opportunistic behavior or knowledge transfer to the vendor.
  • Stronger transactive memory systems (clarity regarding where expertise resides across teams) are significantly associated with reduced opportunism and fewer coordination problems.

What it means for you

CIO / IT Executive

Review all vendor contracts on Monday morning to implement stronger structural safeguards and exit clauses specifically for projects involving high software-specific knowledge, mitigating potential vendor opportunism.

IT Manager

Audit your team's project collaboration tools on Monday morning to establish a clear transactive memory system—explicitly mapping out who holds what domain and technical expertise across both the client and vendor teams to prevent coordination bottlenecks.

Business Strategist

Restructure vendor onboarding plans on Monday morning to mandate dedicated communication channels and joint workflow workshops specifically for projects requiring deep domain knowledge, targeting the root cause of cross-organizational coordination problems.

Researcher

Design a new empirical study on Monday morning to investigate the interaction effects between domain and software knowledge specificity using multi-level modeling on longitudinal outsourcing datasets.

Policymaker

Draft guidelines by Monday morning for public-sector digital transformation tenders that require agencies to separately assess and categorize vendor risks based on domain versus software-specific knowledge requirements.

Summary

This study examines how two distinct forms of client-specific knowledge—software knowledge specificity and domain knowledge specificity—differentially impact outsourcing relationships. The author conducted a matched-pair survey across 73 outsourced software projects in Switzerland and Denmark, pairing vendor developers with client project managers. Ordinary least squares regression models were used to analyze the distinct effects on vendor learning, opportunism, and team coordination problems.

Problem

Prior outsourcing research offers conflicting findings about how relationship-specific knowledge influences governance and project risks, largely because studies treat knowledge specificity as a single, combined construct. In practice, clients often struggle to anticipate whether specific project requirements will trigger vendor lock-in and opportunistic behavior or instead cause communication and coordination breakdowns across organizational boundaries. Disentangling the operational consequences of business knowledge versus software-specific knowledge remains a critical gap.

Transcript
Host: Welcome to A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge. I am Anna Ivy Summers. Today, we are discussing a study titled "Domain or Software? Unpacking Knowledge Specificity and its Relational Consequences in IT Outsourcing," authored by Oliver Krancher and presented at the International Conference on Information Systems in 2026. Alex, what is the core focus of this study?

Expert: Hello Anna. In IT outsourcing, organizations often require vendors to develop specialized knowledge. This study investigates two distinct forms of client-specific knowledge: software knowledge specificity, which relates to understanding the client's internal software architectures and systems, and domain knowledge specificity, which involves the client's unique business processes and operating rules. The author examines how these two types differentially relate to vendor learning, opportunistic behavior, and coordination problems.

Host: That brings us to the core problem. Why has past research produced conflicting results regarding relationship-specific knowledge in IT outsourcing?

Expert: Prior research frequently treated knowledge specificity as a single, combined category. Because of this aggregation, empirical studies reported mixed findings regarding whether specific knowledge helps or harms outsourcing relationships. In practice, organizations struggle to anticipate whether specific requirements will lead to vendor lock-in and opportunism, or instead create cross-boundary communication and coordination breakdowns. This study addresses that gap by separating business domain knowledge from software system knowledge.

Host: How did the author examine this empirically?

Expert: Oliver Krancher conducted a matched-pair survey covering 73 outsourced software development and maintenance projects across Switzerland and Denmark. To reduce single-informant bias, the data paired vendor-side developers with client-side project managers. The study then used ordinary least squares regression models, controlling for factors such as project size, task interdependence, and cloud delivery models, to examine how each knowledge type associates with relational outcomes.

Host: Let us look at the findings. What did the analysis reveal about software knowledge specificity?

Expert: The regression analysis showed that software knowledge specificity is positively and statistically significantly associated with greater knowledge transfer to the vendor, as well as increased opportunistic behavior by the vendor. However, it showed no statistically significant association with coordination problems. When vendors invest heavily in understanding complex, proprietary software systems, they gain an informational advantage that can create client dependence and hold-up hazards.

Host: And what happened when the study examined domain knowledge specificity?

Expert: The pattern was quite different. Domain knowledge specificity had a positive and statistically significant relationship with coordination problems, such as misunderstandings about requirements or integration issues. At the same time, it showed no statistically significant association with opportunistic behavior or vendor knowledge transfer. In these settings, the client typically retains core business expertise rather than transferring it entirely, which creates coordination friction across organizational boundaries rather than vendor lock-in.

Host: The study also examined transactive memory systems. What role did that play?

Expert: The findings showed that when project members clearly understand where expertise resides across teams, there are statistically significant reductions in both opportunistic behavior and coordination problems. Knowing who knows what helps mitigate some of the relational hazards created by specific knowledge.

Host: How can business and IT leaders apply these insights in practice?

Expert: Leaders should avoid treating all project knowledge identically. When projects involve high software knowledge specificity, such as legacy systems or proprietary architectures, the primary risk is vendor lock-in. Managers can address this through structured onboarding, deliberate documentation, knowledge rotation, or multisourcing arrangements to ensure internal teams retain system understanding.

Host: And when domain knowledge specificity is the dominant factor?

Expert: In that case, the primary risk is coordination friction, not opportunism. Managers should focus on bridging business-technical boundaries rather than attempting complete knowledge handoffs. In practice, this means employing iterative development, frequent joint testing, and embedded product owners who can continuously clarify business rules and resolve misunderstandings.

Host: To summarize, software knowledge creates dependence risks that invite opportunism, while domain knowledge creates integration challenges that require ongoing coordination. Recognizing which knowledge type dominates allows managers to choose the appropriate governance structure. Thank you, Alex, for breaking down this study, and thank you to our listeners for joining us on A.I.S. Insights — powered by Living Knowledge.
Artificial Intelligence & Automation Information Systems & Management Human-Computer Interaction Data Analytics & Big Data Digital Transformation & Strategy Cybersecurity & Privacy Cloud & Infrastructure E-Commerce & Digital Platforms Operations & Supply Chain Sustainability & Green IS

knowledge specificity, IT outsourcing, software knowledge, domain knowledge, opportunistic behavior, coordination problems, knowledge transfer